Format: Multi-session unit (2–3 sessions plus home building) | Grades: 2–5
What we did
In January 2015, the Toothpick Bridge Challenge became the unit that introduced students to the design process. We explored why bridges are built and looked at bridge designs in Wheaton and around the world. Then we tested sample toothpick bridges built by our instructors, adding weight to try to break them. (We didn’t bring enough weight to break them!)
Students then learned the design process they would use all year:
- Define the problem
- Collect information
- Brainstorm a design
- Build it
- Get feedback: what’s working, what isn’t
- Improve the design
- Repeat
Students built bridges at home, then brought them in for testing two weeks later. The strongest bridges held two and a half gallons plus 48 ounces of weight. Many students discovered for themselves that triangles are the strongest shape.
Below are the test results, with student reflections that show the design process at work.
|
Held 2 gallons and 2 liters
What Challenges did you go through as you built your bridges?
My bridge cracked so we built more layer
Held 1 Gallon
“Tressel”
Why did you chose to build your bridge the way you did? “Because I wanted it to have a lot of triangles in it and they are the strongest shape.” Held 2 gallons and 2 liters “The Boxcar”
Held 1 and 1/2 gallons
What Challenges did you go through as you built your bridges?
“my sides weren’t strait so I made pyramids and added triangles leaning against each other.” Held one gallon
What Challenges did you go through as you built your bridges?
“When I was making the supports it was hard to have them go together”
Would you do anything different if you build your bridge again?
“If I did my bridge earlier in time I would have made it have more support.”
|
Held 48 Ounces
What Challenges did you go through as you built your bridges?
“When I glued it, it came out of place”
Held 48 ounces
What Challenges did you go through as you built your bridges?
“The A’s kept falling down.” Held 1 Gallon
Why did you chose to build your bridge the way you did?
“Because it has a lot of support” Held 1 Gallon
Why did you chose to build your bridge the way you did?
“Because I wanted it to have a lot of triangles in it and they are the strongest shape” |
Held 48 Ounces
Held 48 ounces Would you do anything different if you build your bridge again?
“I would make it really wide.”
Held 2 and 1/2 gallons and 48 ounces
What Challenges did you go through as you built your bridges?
“Making sure that the patters matched.” |
Standards addressed
- NGSS 3-5-ETS1-1, 3-5-ETS1-2, 3-5-ETS1-3: Define a design problem, generate and compare solutions, and test and improve a prototype.
- NGSS 3-PS2-1: Investigate the effects of balanced and unbalanced forces on an object.
- CCSS Math Practice MP1, MP4, MP5: Persevere in solving problems, model with mathematics, and use tools strategically.
- CCSS 4.G.A.2: Classify two-dimensional figures, including triangles, by their properties.
To bring the Toothpick Bridge Challenge to your school, contact steve@rubberbandproject.org.
